In a recent episode of The View, co-host Sarah Haynes, often regarded as the moderate voice on the panel, delivered a critical diatribe against Catholicism, particularly targeting the Traditional Latin Mass.

Her comments were in response to a speech by Harrison Butker at Benedictine College, where he defended traditional Catholic values.

Sarah Haynes’ Critique

Haynes expressed her disapproval, stating that Butker’s practice of the Traditional Latin Mass, a form of Catholic liturgy predating Vatican II, was extremist and cult-like.

She argued that this form of Catholicism diverges from mainstream practices, comparing it to extreme religious sects in other parts of the world. Haynes emphasized her belief that true Christian faith should focus on the teachings of Jesus rather than strict religious rituals.

“If you’re using this to oppress people or hold them down, you’re not walking with Jesus,” Haynes stated, suggesting that Butker’s approach to Catholicism was more about judgment and less about compassion and understanding.

Counterpoints to Haynes’ View

In a pointed rebuttal, critics argue that Haynes’ understanding of Catholicism is limited. They highlight that the Traditional Latin Mass, or the “Mass of the Ages,” has been a fundamental part of Catholic worship for centuries and is recognized by the Vatican. It’s seen not as a divergent or extremist practice but as a deeply rooted tradition that has shaped the faith and spirituality of countless saints.

“The Traditional Latin Mass is the mass that has formed virtually all of the Saints of History,” noted one commentator, emphasizing its historical significance and continuity within the Church.

Whoopi Goldberg’s Reasoned Response

Interestingly, Whoopi Goldberg, another co-host on The View, provided a more balanced perspective. She defended Butker’s right to express his beliefs, especially in a Catholic college setting. Goldberg highlighted the importance of respecting differing views and underscored the principle of freedom of speech.

“He’s a Catholic guy at a Catholic College talking to Catholic students and Catholic parents and he just expressed Catholicism,” Goldberg stated, advocating for tolerance and respect for diverse religious expressions.

Broader Implications and Reactions

The controversy extended beyond the show, with the NFL and local authorities getting involved. The NFL distanced itself from Butker’s views, reflecting a broader cultural tension between traditional religious beliefs and modern progressive values. Additionally, a tweet from Kansas City inadvertently revealed Butker’s location, leading to public outcry over the potential risk to his safety.

This incident has sparked a larger conversation about religious freedom, the role of traditional practices in modern society, and the extent to which public figures can express their beliefs without facing severe backlash.

Conclusion

Sarah Haynes’ critique of the Traditional Latin Mass has ignited a debate on The View, highlighting contrasting views on Catholicism and religious expression. While Haynes views Butker’s adherence to traditional practices as extreme, others see it as a vital part of Catholic heritage. Whoopi Goldberg’s call for tolerance and respect serves as a reminder of the need for open dialogue and understanding in discussions of faith and belief.